Il Castello in Barryville

Il Castello in Barryville
4 / 5
50 reviews

3438 State Route 97, Barryville, NY 12719-5923, Barryville

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian
  • Pizza
Features
  • Takeout
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Serves Alcohol
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Large groups
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Is it open every day?

They aren't open Mondays. However, I counter what was said by the first respondent. The business takes care of their employees and participates in local happenings. I'm a local to barryville and I know for a fact that if you ask for something specific you get it the way you asked. Try not to read too much into that negative response, and sorry I didn't see this question before her. lol

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Il Castello
VG
Vance Gorke
google
03.01.2021
5/5

Great Italian rest. Love the redesign dining room. far better pizza than you d expect in middle the woods on the river.

Il Castello
sans
google
10.12.2018
5/5

Excellent food but prices went up

Il Castello
mountainrapid
google
09.17.2018
3/5

Pizza use to be better . They changed something a few years ago and just not as good as they were for years.

Il Castello
AK
Amanda King
google
08.27.2018
5/5

Super yummy! Good prices and good servers!

Il Castello
TW
Thomas Weller
google
06.25.2018
2/5

Okay Pizza but the service was real bad rude people I understand what's going on in the world right now but you should treat the people that keep your business going a little better

Il Castello
TL
Tom Lee
google
06.16.2018
4/5

Food was excellent. Ordered was ready under half HR. The chicken parmagnia hero were super huge. You can eat 1/2 for dinner & the other 1/2 for lunch. Service was great served with a smile. The only issue was the clam pastas had too much olive oil. Had to drain the oil out before eating the pastas. I highly suggested to order the olive oil on the side.

Il Castello
SJ
Susan Janssens
google
05.01.2018
5/5

great marguerite pizza. the sauce and mozzarella is so fresh. We stop here often to our second home near there. Service is friendly ….

Il Castello
LM
LSD Mobile
google
04.03.2018
2/5

Ever heard of salt and pepper? Literally no flavor at all, I understand you just reopened but my god

Il Castello
TR
Teri Ranne
google
03.17.2018
5/5

It the best place in Sullivan County for Italian food.

Il Castello
TS
Tim Scully
google
03.09.2018
5/5

Had a great stromboli! The server was very nice

Il Castello
JS
Jeremy Santana Alvarez
google
02.22.2018
5/5

sooo good, this pizza

Il Castello
lkutch
google
11.22.2017
5/5

Fast and hot and tasty food

Il Castello
SR
Susie Robbi
google
11.19.2017
4/5

Had a delicious taco pizza tonight! Quick service and we were well taken care of. Nice to see the decor updated but... could use a good cleaning, window sills are filthy with dust, dirt and dead bugs . We will go back again for the delicious pizza but probably will get takeout next time .

Il Castello
BB
Brett Burkle
google
11.19.2017
4/5

Took out pizza on sunday night, prob the worst pizza i have ever eaten. The dough was over mixed or over kneaded. The pizza sauce neede to have a touch of sugar bc the acid was unbearable. Switch to a low moisture whole milk grande mozzerella will also help not to be so greasy.Im giving this a 4 star bc restaurants in this area are hard to come by and i take critism over my own restaurant which happens to be italian as well (tre amici ristorante italiano)and by tweeking the menu to make it better is what complaints are all about.

Il Castello
JP
J P
google
11.13.2017
5/5

Authentic Italian. No joke

Il Castello
ZT
Zak Tyler
google
11.08.2017
5/5

This place has been a staple in my and my families lives for well over 10 years. So much so, while living in North Carolina this was the first place we would come to while visiting Pizza and pasta are always a safe bet here, but you can't go wrong with much on the menu. Pizza is sold by the slice with a ton of options. Specials and pricing are fair and don't really change.Cash, credit and debit accepted here. The owners Pete and Kelly do so much to help the neighborhood and community.

Il Castello
JL
Jeffrey Liss
google
10.22.2017
4/5

While it is not the "only place in town" it is practically the only place in town to get an acceptable meal at normal meal hours. The menu has all of the regular pizza/Italian restaurant items you would expect at very reasonable prices. Lots of seating and good service.

Il Castello
ch
chris hoover
google
09.05.2017
5/5

Always a good meal. Friendly service too. Salad bar is always fresh, pizza is great and I'm a fan of their baked manicotti. Even when busy they handle it well. No phone service there, but sometimes that's an added bonus.

Il Castello
AR
Anne Roth
google
06.20.2017
4/5

Great food

Il Castello
jp
joseph pentangelo
google
06.13.2017
5/5

Our favorite restaurant in the area. Large portions, fresh salad bar, great specials, good prices. The waitress is friendly, professional and attentive. I highly recommend! Every time we are up at our weekend house, we have a meal at Il Castello!

Il Castello
sc
samuel casad
google
06.11.2017
4/5

Excellent pizza!!!!! Get it extra crispy. And, their blue cheese is delish on their fresh salads. I'd definitely go back in a second. Cheap and extremely friendly service is this cute little town.

Il Castello
kS
kathryn S
google
05.27.2017
5/5

Thin crust regular pie is just like when I was a kid in Queens, NY getting pies from Carlos on Lefferts Blvd or Rosa's on 69 st. and Grand.

Il Castello
bf
bill furler
google
05.07.2017
5/5

Great food, great people

Il Castello
Mary
google
05.04.2017
5/5

We have a summer cottage in Blooming Grove PA and was always looking for some place new to eat. We looked on google maps and found Il Castello in NY only a 25 minute drive away. The car ride through the beautiful PA country roads and down along the Delaware river was so relaxing. We visited here on a Wednesday afternoon in late June. They have a nice little patio area with tables and umbrellas but unfortunately, it was not opened when we visited. Our party ordered a meatball hoagie, pizza, fries, wings and drinks. The plate of fries they brought I had to take home with me there was so much. Very crispy and light and not over salted like some places. The pizza was a little thicker crust but crisp and cheesy. Very good. Meatballs were a nice size as well as the wing bites. Everything we had was delicious and we will be coming back to eat here again.

Il Castello
rs
richard simonelli
google
04.04.2017
5/5

The food is always delicious And if I knew Pete was making pizza I would had a pie

Il Castello
FJ
Frank Jordan
google
04.01.2017
3/5

Pretty good gluten free pizza.

Il Castello
mc
mitch cohen
google
03.03.2017
3/5

Decent food. Friendly staff. Family friendly.

Il Castello
MG
Miguel Girard
google
02.20.2017
2/5

Not here to ruin anyone's livelihood but my experience was nothing to rave about.

Il Castello
PS
Peter Skow
google
02.18.2017
5/5

By far the best pizza and plates of italian cuisine in the region . Owners are very friendly and always there to help you . Also try the garbage pizza, you will not be dissapointed. Enjoy

Il Castello
al
anthony laden
google
02.04.2017
4/5

Nice place clean good food, didn't like it 4 dollars.a beer, but the bathroom was clean, and food was good

Il Castello
DM
Dawn Mims
google
01.22.2017
5/5

Great pizza and great dining! Food is all around excellent!

Il Castello
GC
Grace Criscione
google
01.18.2017
5/5

Great food and pizza.. great service

Il Castello
AC
Android Cellphone
google
01.09.2017
2/5

Had better frozen supermarket pizza. The place was also full of hick Trump supporters

Il Castello
TA
Timothy Aviles
google
11.18.2016
5/5

Just went in. It's the holiday season. The lobby had this amazing model town just sitting there. It was amazingly artistic and beautiful. 5 stars for the amazing pizza and art. Bravo!

Il Castello
ER
Ed Rahfield
google
11.11.2016
5/5

A solid pizza

Il Castello
CF
Cassidy Fanatic
google
10.02.2016
5/5

Awesome Italian cuisine. Friendly wait staff. A definite gem!!!

Il Castello
cw
cat w
google
09.25.2016
5/5

Great food. Good service. Friendly staff

Il Castello
RP
R P
google
09.16.2016
4/5

Excellent pizza, fair prices, family restaurant. Would recommend.

Il Castello
BK
Brendan Kumburis
google
09.09.2016
5/5

This restaurant has great food at reasonable prices don't change a thing

Il Castello
SC
Stephanie Connelly
google
08.20.2016
5/5

This restaurant is consistent. You get a large portion of food for the money. Every item is excellent. From linguini and clam sauce to a burger. The place is always packed so you know The food is being turned over. Staff is excellent. I have never had a bad meal.i have ordered am array of food. Or of all theItalian restaurants in the area this is in the top. You won't go wrong here.

Il Castello
TH
Trevor Hipp
google
06.14.2016
1/5

We’ve ordered pizza from this place on three separate occasions. Each time we asked for our pizza extra extra crispy and every time it came back soggy. There excuse, “vegetables create steam”... I’m sorry, but this pizza is below par, unfortunately it’s the only game in town so it doesn’t have much competition.

Il Castello
MK
Miriam K
google
05.24.2016
5/5

Very quick service and food made correctly

Il Castello
KS
Kate Sutter
google
05.19.2016
5/5

Okay first off HOW CUTE IS THIS PLACE? Really nice staff. A special shout-out to Leslie for being one of the kindest souls in Barryville. She treated us beautifully and always with a smile. The knots are surprisingly great - not too dry - and the pizza was nice. Will definitely come back next time we are in Barryville.

Il Castello
KO
Kevin Owens
google
04.25.2016
5/5

Good food ,large portions and very nice interior.

Il Castello
cf
claudia ferrara
google
04.11.2016
5/5

Delicious delicious food. Service is impeccable! Love coming here for lunch or dinner. Looking forward to going here for my birthday dinner!!😘

Il Castello
RB
Russ Birzescu
google
04.04.2016
5/5

EXCELENT ...FRIENDLY PEOPLE AND THE POZZA WAS EXCELLENT, STOP AND CHECKED THEM OUT !

Il Castello
CB
Candy Bott
google
02.17.2016
5/5

Beautifully renovated, and on trend restaurant! So comfortable! We love this place! It feels like home to us! When we say go for pizza, we mean Il Castillo's! Pizza, Chicken parmesan and pasta, Alfredo fettuccine with sausage or even just spaghetti and meatballs are our go to meals. We also get their quesadillas, and calzones and lasagna, and steak sandwiches! Oh and I can't forget dessert! Tiramisu! Canoli! pumpkin cheesecake! And they have gelato ( I have to try that still) We go here once a week on average! It's worth the wait, sometimes they are busy. We have learned to call ahead especially on weekends in the summer.

Il Castello
AC
Antonio Cerna
google
01.27.2016
5/5

Best pizza in Barryville!

Il Castello
JC
Joe Curreri
google
01.23.2016
5/5

Food and pizza is good service is great and friendly. Best pizza around

Il Castello
ps
pierce stclair
google
01.16.2016
5/5

Great pizza and salad bar. Decor is beautiful and modern. Only complaint is could use a little better brand of coffee

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 18455576400

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!